“”

How to Set Goals for First-Party Data Collection in E-commerce

Tigran Zograbyan
COO and Co-Founder

Food retailers who set strategic first-party data collection goals achieve 2.9X revenue uplift compared to those relying on third-party data, with grocery-specific implementations delivering 3-5% improvements in revenue and profit within 12 months. The challenge isn't whether to collect customer data—it's setting clear, measurable goals that transform raw information into competitive advantages. For grocers, butcher shops, and bakeries using unified commerce platforms, well-defined data collection objectives become the foundation for personalized experiences that drive loyalty and growth in an increasingly digital marketplace.

Key Takeaways

  • Organizations using first-party data strategically achieve 2.9X revenue growth and 1.5X cost savings versus third-party data reliance
  • 71% of consumers expect personalized interactions, yet approximately one-third of marketers can effectively unify collected data
  • Grocery retailers implementing data-driven loyalty programs see 3-5% improvement in revenue and profit with retail media margins exceeding 40%
  • SMART goal frameworks increase success rates for data collection initiatives

Understanding the Fundamentals: First-Party, Third-Party, and Zero-Party Data in E-commerce

Before setting goals, food retailers must understand what types of data exist and their strategic value.

First-party data is information you collect directly from customer interactions with your owned channels: website visits, purchase history, loyalty program behavior, mobile app usage, and in-store transactions. For grocery retailers, this includes dietary preferences captured during online ordering, replenishment cycles for staples like milk and bread, and seasonal purchasing patterns around holidays.

Third-party data comes from external sources that aggregate consumer information across multiple businesses. While historically useful for targeting, over 66% of consumers report this data is 0-50% accurate. With browser cookie deprecation and privacy regulations tightening, third-party data becomes less reliable and more expensive.

Zero-party data represents information customers intentionally share through surveys, preference centers, quizzes, and direct feedback. A bakery asking "Any dietary restrictions we should know?" during checkout collects zero-party data that's both accurate and privacy-compliant because customers willingly provide it.

The value hierarchy is clear: zero-party and first-party data deliver superior accuracy, demonstrate customer trust, comply with privacy regulations like GDPR and CCPA, and enable genuine personalization that 76% of consumers expect but most retailers fail to deliver.

Why First-Party Data Collection is Crucial for Grocery Retailers

Independent food retailers face mounting pressure from major chains with massive budgets and sophisticated data infrastructure. Yet first-party data creates competitive advantages that level the playing field.

Beyond Third-Party Cookie Deprecation: Building Sustainable Customer Relationships

As browsers eliminate third-party cookies, 75% of marketers still rely heavily on this disappearing resource without transition strategies. Food retailers who build first-party data strategies now gain sustainable competitive advantages while competitors scramble to adapt.

Your relationship with local customers creates natural data collection opportunities that Amazon and Instacart can't replicate. When customers share their gluten-free needs or favorite cut of steak, they're trusting you with personal information that enables better service—not surveillance. This trust becomes your moat.

The Power of Personalization: Satisfying Your Customers

Research confirms that most shoppers expect personalized promotions and pricing tailored to their preferences. The grocers Alliance CEO John Ross emphasizes: "All retailers should be looking for ways to capture and harness individual shopper data... The very same characteristics of community and trust that define independents can help us differentiate online, too."

Platforms like LocalExpress's mobile application collect customer behavior data automatically—what products they browse, add to cart, and ultimately purchase—enabling the personalized experiences that transform occasional shoppers into loyal customers.

Crafting SMART Goals for First-Party Data Collection

Vague objectives like "collect more customer data" fail because they lack accountability and direction. The SMART framework transforms ambiguous intentions into actionable targets.

Specific: Defining Clear Data Collection Objectives

Effective goals name exactly what data you'll collect, which customer segments you'll target, and which channels you'll use. Compare these examples:

  • Weak goal: "Get more email addresses"
  • SMART goal: "Increase email subscribers by 500 customers within 6 months through Instagram campaigns, offering a 50% discount via one-time codes for first orders"

For food retailers, specificity might target dietary preference data: "Collect allergen and dietary information from 60% of loyalty members within 3 months through mobile app surveys."

Measurable: Establishing Key Performance Indicators (KPIs)

Every goal requires quantifiable metrics that prove success or failure. LiveRamp's framework identifies four core measurement categories:

  • Cart size metrics: Average order value, items per transaction, basket composition
  • Customer service quality: Response time, issue resolution rate, satisfaction scores
  • Conversion improvements: Browse-to-purchase rate, email click-through, offer redemption
  • Churn reduction: Repeat purchase frequency, customer lifetime value, at-risk customer win-back

A butcher shop might set: "Reduce customer churn by 20% within 6 months for customers who typically purchase weekly but haven't ordered in 14+ days."

Achievable: Setting Realistic and Attainable Goals

Ambitious targets motivate teams, but impossible goals breed cynicism. Start with 1-2 priority use cases that address your biggest business challenges before expanding.

If you currently collect zero dietary preference data, setting a goal to personalize 100% of recommendations within 30 days is unrealistic. Instead: "Capture dietary preferences from 25% of new customers in month one, increasing to 50% by month three."

Consider your current technology, staff capacity, and customer willingness to share when setting targets.

Implementing Effective Data Collection Tools and Strategies

Goals without infrastructure fail. Food retailers need multiple touchpoints collecting complementary data types to build comprehensive customer profiles.

Leveraging Your E-commerce Platform for Customer Insights

Your grocery e-commerce platform captures rich behavioral data automatically:

  • Browse patterns: Products viewed, search terms, category interests
  • Cart behavior: Items added then removed, abandoned carts, wishlist additions
  • Purchase history: SKU-level transaction data, order frequency, seasonal patterns
  • Channel preferences: Mobile versus website usage, delivery versus pickup selection

This passive collection requires no customer effort while building detailed preference profiles.

Maximizing Data from In-Store Technologies

Physical stores offer unique data collection opportunities through modern technology:

Self-ordering kiosks collect detailed data on customer preferences while reducing lines and labor costs. When customers customize sandwich orders or select add-ons, you're capturing zero-party preference data that improves future recommendations.

Scan, Pay and Go enables customers to self-checkout using their mobile phones, creating SKU-level data linked to individual profiles. Unlike traditional POS transactions that only track basket totals, you gain granular insights into shopping paths.

Loyalty programs remain the foundation of grocery first-party data strategies. Retailers implementing best-in-class programs achieve 3-5% improvements in revenue and profit according to Boston Consulting Group research.

Set specific enrollment goals: "Increase loyalty membership from 35% to 55% of monthly customers within one year through point-of-sale prompts."

Harnessing AI for First-Party Data Harmonization and Enrichment

Collecting data across multiple systems creates integration challenges. 69% of marketers state that unifying customer data is their biggest challenge.

Turning Raw Data into Clean, Actionable Insights

Your POS system knows a customer bought "Organic Milk 1%", your e-commerce platform recorded "Horizon Organic 1% Low Fat Milk Half Gallon", and your inventory management lists "MILK ORG 1% HOR 64oz". Without data harmonization, these appear as three different products rather than purchase pattern signals.

AI data fusion platforms solve this by:

  • Seamlessly integrating data from POS, ERP, supplier catalogs, and online channels
  • Minimizing discrepancies through intelligent matching and deduplication
  • Enriching product data with nutritional information, allergens, and dietary attributes
  • Maintaining real-time sync so inventory and customer profiles stay current

Retailers using AI-driven data harmonization reduce onboarding time from months to weeks while unlocking retail media revenue streams with 40%+ profit margins—significantly exceeding core grocery margins.

Automating Onboarding and Maintaining Real-time Accuracy

Set goals around data quality, not just quantity: "Achieve 95% product data accuracy across all channels within 90 days through automated AI harmonization, reducing customer service inquiries about product details by 30%."

This quality focus prevents the "data graveyard" problem where retailers collect massive amounts of unusable information.

Building a Robust Customer Data Platform (CDP) for Unified Insights

Customer Data Platforms centralize information from every touchpoint—website, mobile app, kiosk, POS, email, loyalty program—into single customer profiles that power personalization.

Integrating Diverse Data Sources for a 360-Degree Customer View

When a customer named Sarah buys gluten-free bread in-store using her loyalty card, orders organic vegetables through your mobile app, and clicks an email about your new vegan product line, these should connect to one Sarah profile—not three disconnected data points.

Omnichannel ecommerce solutions with centralized dashboards make this integration possible. The platform unifies transaction data, behavioral data, preference data, and engagement data across all channels.

Set integration goals: "Connect all customer touchpoints into unified profiles for 80% of loyalty members within 6 months, enabling cross-channel personalization."

Powering Personalized Marketing and Loyalty Programs

Once data unifies, activation becomes possible. Your goal isn't single-brand loyalty—it's share of wallet within your store through personalized experiences.

Email subject line personalization alone boosts click-through rates 27% according to Experian research. Simple tactics like "Your favorite artisan bread is back, [Name]" outperform generic promotional emails.

Advanced retailers use unified data for retail media partnerships, creating new revenue streams by allowing brand partners to advertise to relevant customer segments while maintaining white-labeled experiences.

Ensuring Data Privacy and Compliance in Your Collection Efforts

Privacy violations destroy customer trust permanently. Food retailers handling health-sensitive data like allergen information face heightened compliance requirements.

Building Customer Trust Through Transparent Data Practices

Despite 81% of customers feeling they have little control over their data, retailers who demonstrate responsible stewardship build competitive advantages. Your privacy practices should:

  • Explain clearly what data you collect and why it benefits customers
  • Offer explicit opt-ins rather than pre-checked boxes
  • Provide easy opt-outs and preference management
  • Show immediate value from shared data (personalized recommendations, faster checkout)
  • Respect boundaries between helpful personalization and invasive suggestions

Set transparency goals: "Implement customer preference center allowing 100% control over data sharing and communications, with 70% of customers actively managing preferences within 3 months."

Handling Regulatory Landscapes for Responsible Data Management

GDPR, CCPA, and 20+ state privacy laws create complex compliance requirements. Key principles include:

  • Consent must be freely given, specific, informed, and unambiguous
  • Data minimization: Collect only what's necessary for stated purposes
  • Right to deletion: Customers can request complete data removal
  • Breach notification: 72-hour reporting windows under GDPR

Platforms providing ADA and WCAG accessibility support alongside industry-standard security protocols demonstrate commitment to customer protection—a key LocalExpress differentiator.

Measuring Success and Iterating Your Data Collection Strategy

Goals without measurement become suggestions. Establish review cycles to evaluate performance and adapt strategies.

Track these core metrics:

  • Collection rate: Percentage of customers sharing requested data
  • Data completeness: Average profile fields populated per customer
  • Activation rate: How much collected data actually powers personalization
  • ROI metrics: Revenue lift from personalized campaigns versus generic approaches
  • Privacy compliance: Opt-out rates, preference center usage, consent documentation

Food retailers should run A/B tests comparing personalized experiences to control groups. If email subject line personalization generates 27% higher CTR, measure whether product recommendation personalization drives similar basket size improvements.

Set review goals: "Conduct monthly data strategy reviews measuring collection rates, activation effectiveness, and ROI, adjusting tactics based on performance."

Why LocalExpress is the Unified Platform Built for Food Retail Data Success

While many e-commerce platforms collect customer data, LocalExpress delivers unique advantages specifically designed for grocers, butcher shops, and bakeries seeking to compete through superior personalization.

AI-Native Unified Commerce: LocalExpress integrates every customer touchpoint—website, mobile app, self-service kiosks, and POS—into one platform that automatically captures and unifies first-party data.

Purpose-Built for Food Retail: The platform handles variable-weight items, made-to-order customizations through prepared food solutions, dietary restriction tracking, and seasonal inventory patterns that generic platforms struggle to manage.

Seamless POS Synchronization: Real-time inventory management with predictive AI eliminates price inconsistencies and stock discrepancies that frustrate customers and corrupt data quality.

Accelerated Implementation: While enterprise CDPs require months of implementation, LocalExpress offers quick setup with 24/7 technical support. The AI data fusion module automates catalog management, reducing onboarding to 5-14 days.

Retail Media Revenue: LocalExpress's retail media platform allows you to monetize first-party data by partnering with brand suppliers who pay to advertise to relevant customer segments, creating the 40%+ margin revenue streams identified by BCG.

For food retailers serious about achieving first-party data collection goals, LocalExpress provides the comprehensive, AI-powered unified platform that turns customer information into competitive advantage.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the difference between first-party, second-party, and third-party data?

First-party data comes directly from your customer interactions and is the most accurate and compliant. Second-party data is another company’s first-party data shared through partnerships, offering reliable but indirect insights. Third-party data comes from aggregators and is now less than 50% accurate due to browser restrictions and shrinking access.

Why is collecting first-party data becoming more important for e-commerce grocery stores?

With third-party cookies disappearing and 75% of marketers still relying on them, grocery retailers need first-party data to meet rising personalization expectations—71% of consumers demand relevance. This data powers dietary insights, replenishment cycles, loyalty strategies, and retail media programs with 40%+ margins.

How can I set measurable goals for increasing my first-party data collection?

SMART goals turn vague intentions into measurable outcomes, such as “Gain 500 email subscribers in 6 months through Instagram 10%-off campaigns.” Grocery retailers can set targets for loyalty enrollment, dietary preference capture, cart-abandonment reduction, or revenue lift by clearly defining the data needed, the channel, the segment, the timeline, and how success is measured.

What tools can LocalExpress offer to help me collect and manage first-party data effectively?

LocalExpress unifies customer data across touchpoints through its mobile app, self-ordering kiosks, and AI data fusion module that harmonizes POS, inventory, and online activity. Real-time synchronization ensures accuracy, while dashboards reveal behavior patterns. Its retail media platform also monetizes first-party data via CPG partnerships.

How does data privacy impact first-party data collection in e-commerce?

Laws like GDPR, CCPA, and 20+ U.S. state privacy rules require consent, transparency, and deletion rights, with CCPA fines up to $7,500 per violation. Strong compliance builds trust, encouraging customers to share data when value is clear—for example, exchanging dietary preferences for personalized recommendations.

Subscribe to Local Express for monthly updates on technology and eCommerce