“”

12 Tips for Your Online Grocery Personalization

Tigran Zograbyan
COO and Co-Founder

Online grocery personalization has shifted from a competitive advantage to a basic customer expectation. Independent grocers and regional chains can now compete with major retailers by implementing AI-powered personalization strategies through unified commerce platforms that connect physical stores with digital channels. The data proves the urgency: weekly online purchases have grown 23% since 2020, while 59% of shoppers now shop for groceries online regularly. Yet most grocers struggle to deliver personalized experiences that match these rising expectations.

Key Takeaways

  • 86% of consumers expect personalized experiences, yet only 11% of grocers deliver meaningful personalization—creating a significant opportunity
  • Personalization can reduce acquisition costs by 50% and lift revenue by 5-15% for grocery retailers
  • First-party data collection through loyalty programs and branded apps has become essential as 78% of brands now prioritize it over third-party sources
  • Mobile personalization drives significantly higher engagement through push notifications and context-aware features
  • Budget-conscious personalization focusing on savings discovery outperforms premium upselling strategies, with 78% of shoppers prioritizing value

1. Build a Unified Customer Data Foundation Across All Channels

Effective personalization starts with a single customer view that connects every touchpoint. When shoppers interact with your brand through your website, mobile app, in-store kiosks, or physical checkout, each interaction should inform the next. This unified approach enables you to track preferences, purchase history, and behavioral patterns across channels.

Essential Data Points to Collect

  • Purchase frequency and timing patterns
  • Product preferences and brand affinities
  • Dietary restrictions and nutritional preferences
  • Shopping channel preferences (delivery, pickup, in-store)
  • Basket composition and category spending
  • Response to promotions and price sensitivity
  • Device usage and browsing behavior

Implementation Steps

Start by integrating your point-of-sale system with your online ordering platform. This synchronization ensures that whether a customer buys organic milk in-store or online, their preference is recorded and reflected across all channels. LocalExpress's omnichannel ecommerce solution synchronizes in-store and online inventory through a centralized management dashboard, creating the unified data foundation necessary for personalization at scale.

Next, implement customer account creation incentives. Offer a 10% discount on first online orders or exclusive digital coupons to encourage shoppers to create profiles. This transforms anonymous transactions into valuable first-party data while providing immediate customer value.

Why This Matters

Only 4% of grocers have scaled advanced personalization capabilities, primarily because they lack unified customer data. Fragmented systems that treat online and in-store as separate entities cannot deliver the consistent experiences customers expect. By building this foundation first, you enable every subsequent personalization strategy to work more effectively.

2. Personalize Product Recommendations Using AI-Driven Insights

AI-powered recommendation engines analyze purchase patterns to predict what customers want before they search for it. Unlike manual merchandising that relies on broad demographic assumptions, machine learning identifies individual preferences and surfaces relevant products at the right moment.

How AI Recommendations Work

Modern systems use multiple algorithms simultaneously—some analyze purchase frequency to predict when you'll need milk again, while others identify complementary products based on what similar shoppers bought together. A customer who regularly purchases gluten-free pasta will see gluten-free sauce recommendations, while someone buying organic produce gets shown organic dairy alternatives.

Recommendation Types to Implement

  • Replenishment predictions: Alert customers when they're likely running low on frequently purchased items
  • Complementary products: Suggest items commonly purchased together (pasta sauce with pasta, coffee filters with coffee)
  • Seasonal recommendations: Promote grilling items to customers with summer cookout purchase histories
  • New product discovery: Introduce items aligned with established preferences
  • Smart substitutions: Offer alternatives when preferred items are out of stock

The order fulfillment system from LocalExpress includes AI-powered product substitutions that learn customer preferences over time, ensuring that when your shopper's preferred brand of Greek yogurt is unavailable, the system suggests alternatives based on their past acceptance of substitutions rather than generic replacements.

Measurable Impact

Retailers implementing AI recommendations see significant results. Conversion rates increase substantially when investing in personalization technology, while basket sizes grow as customers discover relevant products they wouldn't have found through browsing alone.

3. Create Personalized Mobile App Experiences for Your Shoppers

Mobile has become a primary shopping channel, with 23% growth in weekly online grocery purchases since 2020. Your branded mobile app serves as the most intimate touchpoint with customers, enabling personalization that web browsers can't match.

Mobile Personalization Strategies

Push Notification Personalization: Generic "sale this week" notifications get ignored. Instead, send targeted messages based on individual shopping patterns. A customer who buys organic produce every Monday receives a "Your favorite organic strawberries are back in stock" notification Monday morning. This approach drives significantly higher engagement compared to generic messaging.

Personalized Home Screen: Configure your app to display different content for different customer segments. New customers see a simplified interface highlighting popular items and easy navigation, while loyal customers get quick access to their frequently purchased items and personalized deals.

Location-Based Offers: When a customer approaches your store, trigger a notification about in-store-only specials or remind them about items on their shopping list that are available for immediate pickup.

Smart Shopping Lists: Enable features that auto-populate shopping lists based on purchase history and cycles. If a customer buys coffee every two weeks, the app suggests adding it to their list on week two.

LocalExpress's mobile application provides a drag-and-drop app builder that creates fully branded experiences with self-checkout capabilities through scan-and-go functionality, transforming your mobile app from a simple ordering tool into a personalized shopping assistant.

Implementation Priority

Focus first on purchase history integration and personalized product rows before adding complex features. Start with a "Buy Again" section showing frequently purchased items, then layer in recommendations and notifications as you gather more data.

4. Implement Personalized Pricing and Promotions Strategies

With 78% of shoppers budget-conscious and many increasingly choosing private-label products, personalized pricing focused on value optimization drives more loyalty than premium upselling.

Value-Driven Personalization Tactics:

Household-Size Pricing: A family of five that regularly buys large quantities should see bulk-buy promotions prominently featured, while single-person households get smaller package deals highlighted.

Loyalty Milestone Rewards: Ocado increased subscription sign-ups by 13.5% through gamified progress markers between the first and fifth purchases. Rather than generic "spend $X, save $Y" offers, create personalized milestones based on individual shopping patterns.

Category-Specific Discounts: If a customer primarily shops organic produce but rarely buys organic dairy, offer targeted promotions on organic milk and yogurt to expand their organic purchasing.

Basket Recovery Offers: When customers abandon carts, send personalized recovery emails highlighting any items that were on sale or offering a small discount on their specific abandoned items rather than generic promotional codes.

Multi-Buy Optimization: Ocado saw a 55% increase in add-to-cart rates by prominently placing bulk-buy offers in personalized product rows. Surface multi-buy deals matched to household size and purchase frequency.

LocalExpress's retail media platform delivers personalized pricing promotions and product-based retail media ads, enabling you to partner with CPG brands for targeted offers that benefit both your customers and your bottom line. You earn revenue from brand partnerships while customers receive relevant deals.

Transparency Matters:

Around 48% appreciate personalization convenience but only if data is secure, while approximately 40% don't trust companies to use data ethically. Make your personalization logic transparent—explain that you're suggesting bulk deals because they typically buy larger quantities, not because you're charging different base prices.

5. Optimize Online Grocery Shopping Delivery for Individual Preferences

Delivery personalization extends beyond product selection to the entire fulfillment experience. Customers develop strong preferences about delivery windows, driver interactions, and substitution handling that directly impact satisfaction and retention.

Delivery Personalization Elements:

Preferred Delivery Windows: Track which time slots customers consistently choose and prioritize showing available slots near their preferences. A customer who always chooses evening delivery sees evening slots first, reducing search friction.

Delivery Instructions Memory: Store and auto-populate special delivery instructions like gate codes, preferred drop-off locations, or contactless delivery preferences so customers don't re-enter them with every order.

Driver Assignment Preferences: When possible, assign repeat customers to familiar drivers who know their delivery preferences and location quirks. This builds relationships and reduces delivery errors.

Pickup vs. Delivery Intelligence: Some customers alternate between delivery and curbside pickup based on order size or urgency. Your system should recognize these patterns and suggest the appropriate fulfillment method.

LocalExpress's last-mile delivery management platform supports on-demand and scheduled delivery with complete data ownership for white-labeled, personalized customer experiences. The system integrates with 100+ delivery networks while maintaining your brand identity and customer relationship data.

Flexible Fulfillment Options

Around 71% of grocers are now using data to optimize fulfillment and delivery routes. By analyzing customer delivery preferences alongside geographic data, you can create efficient routes that also meet individual customer expectations for delivery timing and handling.

Cost Savings

The platform enables you to reduce delivery costs through AI-powered routing while maintaining the personalized experience customers expect. Multi-location management with centralized control allows enterprise-scale efficiency with store-level personalization flexibility.

6. Enrich Product Data to Enable Better Personalization

Poor product data undermines every personalization effort. When your system can't distinguish between regular pasta and gluten-free pasta, or doesn't know which products are organic, vegan, or allergen-free, recommendations become irrelevant or even harmful.

Essential Product Attributes for Personalization:

  • Dietary classifications (gluten-free, vegan, kosher, halal, keto)
  • Allergen information (contains nuts, dairy, soy, etc.)
  • Nutritional data (calories, protein, sugar content)
  • Ingredient lists for preference matching
  • Organic and sustainability certifications
  • Brand manufacturer relationships
  • Product size and unit variations
  • Preparation requirements (ready-to-eat, needs cooking)

The Data Quality Challenge:

Most grocers inherit product data from multiple sources—POS systems, supplier feeds, marketplace catalogs—each with different formats and completeness levels. A single product might appear with three different descriptions across three channels, preventing effective personalization.

LocalExpress's AI data fusion module utilizes advanced AI to enhance product data and minimize discrepancies across sources. The system seamlessly integrates and harmonizes data from your POS, ERP systems, and supplier catalogs, creating a master product database enriched with the attributes necessary for accurate personalized recommendations.

Implementation Process:

Start with your top 500 products by revenue. Ensure these have complete attribute tagging for dietary preferences, allergens, and key nutritional information. This covers the majority of customer purchases while you work on enriching your full catalog.

Automation Advantage:

Manual data enrichment becomes unsustainable at scale. The AI-driven approach automates the onboarding process, achieving faster market entry for new products while maintaining real-time inventory accuracy through continuous synchronization. This means new specialty items get proper classification immediately, making them discoverable to customers with matching preferences.

Customer Impact:

When a shopper filters for "vegan" products, clean data ensures they see genuinely vegan options without missing items due to incomplete tagging. This builds trust and prevents the frustration of discovering non-compliant products in search results.

7. Use Customer Experience Data to Refine Personalization Over Time

Personalization is not a set-it-and-forget-it initiative. The most successful implementations create feedback loops that continuously improve based on customer responses and behavioral data.

Metrics That Matter

  • Recommendation Acceptance Rate – % of recommended products actually purchased; helps identify top-performing algorithms

  • Substitution Approval Rate – % of accepted vs. rejected substitutions; flags categories needing better matches

  • Notification Engagement – open, click-through, and conversion rates; optimize via A/B testing content and timing

  • Personalization Impact on Cart Value – compare average basket size for personalized vs. generic merchandising
  • Customer Retention by Segment – reveals which customer groups respond best to savings, convenience, or other personalization types

Continuous Optimization Framework

Deploy weekly testing cycles rather than waiting for perfect implementations. Test one variable at a time—notification timing, recommendation placement, promotion types—measuring impact before rolling out broadly.

Building Organizational Capability

A significant majority of businesses are now using AI-driven personalization, but success requires more than technology. Create cross-functional team rooms integrating technology staff, merchandising teams, and marketing departments to review data and make collaborative decisions.

Customer Feedback Integration

Direct customer input complements behavioral data. Survey customers about their personalization preferences, asking specific questions like "How often would you like delivery reminder notifications?" or "Do you prefer automatic substitutions or approval requests?" This explicit preference data works alongside implicit behavioral signals.

8. Scale Personalization Across Multiple Store Locations

Regional chains and multi-location independents face unique personalization challenges: balancing corporate consistency with local relevance. A customer shopping at your downtown location has different needs than one at your suburban store, even within the same chain.

Multi-Location Personalization Strategies

  • Location-based inventory – Surface items stocked at the shopper’s preferred store

  • Regional preferences – Tailor offers (e.g., single-serve near campuses, bulk in suburbs)

  • Local suppliers – Feature community/seasonal products to differentiate from chains

  • Central control, local flex – Corporate sets strategy; stores adjust promos to community

  • Unified yet per-store – Use an omnichannel platform to sync locations, manage separate inventories, and keep one customer profile across stores

Delivery Management at Scale

The delivery management platform offers multi-location management with centralized control and store-level flexibility, enabling you to personalize delivery experiences while benefiting from enterprise-scale routing efficiency and cost savings.

Enterprise Benefits

Chains can analyze customer behavior across all locations to identify successful personalization tactics, then deploy them systemwide while respecting local variations. A promotion structure that drives engagement in one market gets tested in others with local product substitutions.

Implementation Timeline

Start personalization at a single pilot location, measure results thoroughly, then roll out to additional stores in phases. This approach reduces risk while building internal expertise and customer data before enterprise-wide deployment.

9. Leverage First-Party Data Through Loyalty Programs

Third-party cookies are being phased out (with timelines extending into 2025 and beyond), increasing the importance of first-party data collection through loyalty programs. 78% of brands now consider first-party data the most valuable source for personalization, up from just 37% in 2022.

Modern Loyalty Program Design

  • Beyond points – Reward personal goals (e.g., sustainability, health) not just spend

  • Tiered engagement – Milestone perks that feel exclusive; e.g., Sephora drives ~80% of transactions via loyalty members

  • Data-for-value clarity – Explain benefits of sharing data (e.g., dietary prefs → tailored recipes & discounts)

  • Progressive profiling – Start with basics; add preferences over time via optional quizzes/surveys with instant rewards

Loyalty Integration Points

Connect loyalty programs across all touchpoints—mobile apps, kiosks, online ordering, and in-store checkout. A customer should earn and redeem rewards seamlessly regardless of shopping channel.

Gamification Elements

Ocado's approach of creating progress markers between the first and fifth purchase proved more effective than focusing solely on first-purchase optimization. The fifth purchase milestone matters more for long-term retention, suggesting personalized engagement programs should focus on nurturing customers through early purchases.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is online grocery personalization and why does it matter?

Personalization uses customer data and AI to tailor recommendations, promotions, substitutions, and delivery options to each shopper. It matters because most grocers still don’t deliver it—only 11% achieve meaningful personalization—while leaders see ~50% lower acquisition costs and 5–15% revenue lifts.

How can small grocery stores compete with major retailers on personalization?

Lean into local knowledge and relationships, then layer an AI-powered platform that unifies POS, ecommerce, mobile, and kiosks for a single customer view. With many grocers investing in AI in 2025, focus on loyalty-driven first-party data and community-relevant experiences rather than matching big-box catalogs.

What customer data do I need to start personalizing my online grocery store?

Begin with what you already have: purchase history, product preferences, and shopping frequency. Add simple preference fields (dietary needs, delivery/pickup choices), then refine with behavior signals over time—this targeted approach outperforms chasing a “perfect” 360° profile. A unified platform syncs data across in-store, online, mobile, and kiosks.

How does AI improve personalization in online grocery shopping delivery?

AI predicts replenishment, surfaces complementary items, and learns substitution preferences; for fulfillment, it aligns routes with preferred time windows and adapts to delivery instructions. The AI-powered system accelerates picking with smart store mapping and continually improves from feedback—no constant rule rewrites required.

Can I personalize both my online store and physical store experience?

Yes—connecting channels multiplies impact. Use self-ordering kiosks and scan-and-go to recognize shoppers and surface “buy again” items or tailored deals, while POS data feeds online recommendations—so discoveries in one channel inform the next visit in the other.

Subscribe to Local Express for monthly updates on technology and eCommerce